Friday, 14 October 2016

On Grades

I remember teaching a Photoshop course one summer in Bahrain many, many years ago. There were two sisters separated by a year in the course and due to some technicality or another, the elder one got an 87 and the younger an 88. This caused the elder one (who was clearly an overachiever) quite a lot of discomfort and I had to pretend to find a mistake in my correction so that both sisters got the same grade.

I think students cannot look at a grade mark without comparing with their friends, their classmates, even the students they dislike. It's inevitable - as absolute values, they mean nothing. This is different from what we teachers see these grades as: a way of telling the students how much of the material they have shown to understand.

In this program, we only have a pass and a fail grade, but this has not stopped me in the least from putting my all into my work. I want to excel, I want to learn. This is much stronger than the feelings I had in school where - despite the fact that I was graded - I did not care if I excelled or not. I knew I could never get the highest grade in the class (for numerous reasons), so I was only concerned with passing. I saw any attempt at trying to excel to be a waste of time.

I have given the thought of grading a lot of thought and, to be honest, if I had absolute freedom on how I would run my class, I would not use grades of any form. I would reduce it to a pass/fail. I think there are many other incentives that students want to work hard. Students will know about entrance exams for universities for example; and they may desire reference letters. Mostly, without having to worry about grades, they might feel more willing to explore, to experiment, to make mistakes, to follow poor paths. Imagine, for example, if a computer education student or an art students or a creative writing student had to do a project in which the rubric required them to hit certain points. They would probably be less likely to experiment, which is the key aspect of creativity. I imagine we have killed a great deal of opportunity, of art, of innovation -  because of our obsession with trying to make it easier to evaluate people.


Stills from a stop-motion music video I directed a few years: "Moment" by the Crickets of Cascadia (Watch Full Video Here: Clip related to grades starts around 1:20 mark).

No comments:

Post a Comment