As a teacher candidate (and a former teacher in other contexts besides high school) I find that the first two points the authors make regarding being a reflective teacher to be indisputable. A good teacher has to be open to new ideas - and open to rejecting new ideas, which is just as important. This leads to the point about responsibility, which is the one that weighs on my mind a lot when I am teaching. The two are almost in contrast - since any new idea (or even tested ideas that are new to the teacher) require some getting used to and may not actually work. The question for me is whether this becomes a gamble with the students' learning. To take an example from the class, most of the people I discussed the "flipped classroom" with were very keen on trying the idea, as am I, but there are major questions of it not working the way we hoped it would if students decide to take advantage of the laxity. These are questions I am still wrestling with.
Wholeheartedness is the one I have the most trouble with. The criticism the authors had towards "Mary Smith" seemed to me somewhat fair. Perhaps "Mary Smith" was too idealistic, but is it fair to say that a reflective teacher can deal with any educational situation? Are all school environments conducive to learning? I feel that there are so many powerful extraneous factors that influence how receptive students are to teaching (and I am not including the students themselves in that list), that there are situations where what is required is an overhaul of the teaching structure. For example, I used to teach an ESL school which had very strict rules regarding speaking languages other than English. A teacher who believed that students should be allowed to speak their first language as a facilitation to picking up English was not allowed to put this idea into practice. If the students rebelled against this and the teacher did not agree with the rule, then the teacher would have to either go against the students or the school, neither one an optimal solution.

No comments:
Post a Comment