In some of our other courses we learned about Gardner's Theory of Multiple Intelligences - a controversial theory that posits that there are several different intelligences which can be utilized by educators and learners. In addition to intelligences that are catered to in school curricula - e.g. logical-mathematial, visual-spatial, linguistic, musical, bodily-kinesthetic - there are also some which tend to be ignored. Among these is the naturalistic intelligence, the intelligence that "understands" nature. Much of the article focuses on how modern scientific methods abstract things so much to the point that this intelligence is marginalized, and it does a great disservice to any students who possess that intelligence to ignore it in our curriculum.
There are many ways a garden could be used to teach mathematics - there's geometry in both the natural and man-made artifacts; a great deal of arithmetic and estimation in determining amounts of water, seeds, and soils; and the ability to do real-life word problems. A big belief I hold is that teaching mathematics MUST include teaching the usefulness of mathematics, since nothing kills interest or retention more than the idea that it is a purely cognitive exercise.
I do have concerns as to why a garden would be the right teaching tool for me. To quote the article, "In our… gardens, outdoor classrooms are not just indoor classrooms moved outside… the living world teaches,inspires and speaks."
I grew up in a very different climate from the one in Vancouver, and walking around the campus garden yesterday, feeling, listening, touching, and smelling the plants really emphasized that point. Bahrain is a very arid country, and the land is not suitable for growing a variety of plants. I wondered as I walked around: if there is a connection between the land and the people on it, does the climate and the flora have an influence on the "personality" of a culture? It's a very complex question, but I was overwhelmed by a sense of being unqualified to teach anything in the garden - I almost felt like a "tourist".
The other problem I noted is also alluded to in the article: "If school gardens were there for other purposes (for example, to be decorative, or solely to provide food for the school cafeteria, or to be a meditative space for students and staff), they would be in danger of being considered marginal and non-essential to the project of the school, and it would be easy to justify paving them over again."
I find it difficult to utilize the garden for multiple maths lessons, so that it would be necessary for other teachers to get involved in the garden for their lessons. This would require a collaborative effort among many disciplines. Much of this depends on the school culture, but I expect that, since many teacher candidates are taking this idea in now and will be meeting each other again in their professional careers, more and more schools will start incorporating gardens into their schools.
Fascinating to think about the relationship between cultures and 'the land' (and climate, and plants, and birds, and...) When I first moved to BC from Ontario, I also felt like I was a tourist from a foreign planet. Everything was so big here -- the forest smelled different from those in my home place -- I didn't know the names of the trees! And I immediately started meeting fellow students who identified their lives with the life cycle of the salmon, or the orca... not a familiar thing for an Ontario gal. With time (about two years, I'd say), I started to miss the mountains, oceans and huge trees when I was away, and I began to be of this place. I think it will happen for you too. It's almost a visceral feeling of change. We are really 'of the soil' of the places we live, even literally: our bones are made of the minerals we eat, which come from the soil itself.
ReplyDeleteI like the idea that learning gardens at schools must involve interdisciplinary collaboration. That's a great thing to aim for!