I think that outside of formal education there are plenty of places where learning happens without the use of marks.
My daughter (who is 2) has pretty much learned everything she knows without the use of marks - and that was true for all of us.
There's also self-learning. Most of what I learned in my life came from outside of school. Often, what I was interested in was not included in the syllabus. For example, I learned to program using my dad's old computer, some of his textbooks and a lot of trial and error. I learned to type by writing stories and scripts on a very slow computer. I learned a lot about other countries through reading and watching documentaries. Many students who are not good at school will have encyclopedic knowledge on subjects that matter to them - just ask my 10-year old nephew anything about dinosaurs and you'll see.
Apprenticeship also happens without marks. The master assesses whether you are ready or not to handle a certain job, and when you are ready to go out on your own. Many coaches do not give letter grades either - success and failure can be assessed by whether a player makes the team or not, or whether the team is successful. But in reality, in all of these fields, most people continue with the task because the real success is there ability to do something they enjoy.
My daughter (who is 2) has pretty much learned everything she knows without the use of marks - and that was true for all of us.
There's also self-learning. Most of what I learned in my life came from outside of school. Often, what I was interested in was not included in the syllabus. For example, I learned to program using my dad's old computer, some of his textbooks and a lot of trial and error. I learned to type by writing stories and scripts on a very slow computer. I learned a lot about other countries through reading and watching documentaries. Many students who are not good at school will have encyclopedic knowledge on subjects that matter to them - just ask my 10-year old nephew anything about dinosaurs and you'll see.
Apprenticeship also happens without marks. The master assesses whether you are ready or not to handle a certain job, and when you are ready to go out on your own. Many coaches do not give letter grades either - success and failure can be assessed by whether a player makes the team or not, or whether the team is successful. But in reality, in all of these fields, most people continue with the task because the real success is there ability to do something they enjoy.
Lovely writing and ideas, Ali! It's good to keep in mind all the learning we all do outside of the structures of schooling. Some of people's most amazing learning (of language, movement, social interactions, story, general knowledge of the world...) takes place when we are small children and informally.
ReplyDelete