QUOTE 1: "It is important that teachers understand the positive as well as the possible negative consequences of praising students… praise creates dilemmas."
This section resonated with me personally. I grew up in a country where English is a second language, but I had already learned the language from living abroad. Thus, I was at a major advantage in the subject and was overly-praised from my grammar, vocabulary and accent. This only lead to resentment from the other students, which in turn led to name-calling. Back then, I only felt anger and confusion, but now I see things from the other students' perspectives. Imagine trying to learn something as a beginner and being placed in a classroom with a student who has been given a running start and then having the teacher compare you unfavourably to them (which is what praise clan look like to those not being praised.) Teachers should make an effort not to praise students for things they already know, but for how hard they work to learn something new - after all, the job of the teacher is to foster learning not to teach kids to rest on their laurels.
QUOTE 2: "One could even say… the teacher cannot help but be “unreflective” in the curious sense that the classroom teacher must constantly act on the spot and cannot step back and postpone acting in order to first reflect on the various alternatives to this action and consequences of the various alternatives."
It is often said that there is no substitute for experience, and I think that applies just as well in education as it does anywhere where you have to think "on the spot". I think an apt analogy would be an athlete, say a football player, who has to make dozens of snap decisions in the middle of the game but can reflect on them later, perhaps with the help of a coach or game footage. The difference, of course, is in the nature of the decisions, where the athlete deals with the physical and strategic realities of the sport, while teachers contend with a lot of psychological and pedagogical issues. One of the hardest things I have had to deal with is "reading" what a student's intention is in making a remark that may seem inappropriate. I have had students make (and I have made myself) comments that on the surface sound rude, but could just be a misstatement (young people, after all, often have trouble expressing themselves). Conversely, I have had students say things that I took to be in jest when they were dead serious. Over time, I have learned a few things to help me in my teaching: For example, I learn to ask students for clarification and restatement - a skill we expect students to learn themselves.
QUOTE 3: "But it is obviously not possible to act thoughtfully and self-confidently while doubting oneself at the same time."
This quote was interesting for me because it puts me in two minds. On the one hand, it is true, students look up their teachers as figures of authority (intellectual, emotional, moral) and any sign of weakness can be disruptive to the class dynamic. I have had teachers who allowed their doubt to show and there were students who exploited that. On the other hand, I have had teachers who, by never doubting themselves, became authoritarian in the classroom. I think there needs to be a balance between being confident and being reflective, and I think (in opposition to the author) that there are occasions where the teacher needs to be reflective in class. Perhaps the teacher can choose those moments to reflect appropriately - for example, while the students are working on a problem or writing exercise. In any case, it is interesting that even the question of self-reflection is one that teachers need to self-reflect upon.
This section resonated with me personally. I grew up in a country where English is a second language, but I had already learned the language from living abroad. Thus, I was at a major advantage in the subject and was overly-praised from my grammar, vocabulary and accent. This only lead to resentment from the other students, which in turn led to name-calling. Back then, I only felt anger and confusion, but now I see things from the other students' perspectives. Imagine trying to learn something as a beginner and being placed in a classroom with a student who has been given a running start and then having the teacher compare you unfavourably to them (which is what praise clan look like to those not being praised.) Teachers should make an effort not to praise students for things they already know, but for how hard they work to learn something new - after all, the job of the teacher is to foster learning not to teach kids to rest on their laurels.
QUOTE 2: "One could even say… the teacher cannot help but be “unreflective” in the curious sense that the classroom teacher must constantly act on the spot and cannot step back and postpone acting in order to first reflect on the various alternatives to this action and consequences of the various alternatives."
It is often said that there is no substitute for experience, and I think that applies just as well in education as it does anywhere where you have to think "on the spot". I think an apt analogy would be an athlete, say a football player, who has to make dozens of snap decisions in the middle of the game but can reflect on them later, perhaps with the help of a coach or game footage. The difference, of course, is in the nature of the decisions, where the athlete deals with the physical and strategic realities of the sport, while teachers contend with a lot of psychological and pedagogical issues. One of the hardest things I have had to deal with is "reading" what a student's intention is in making a remark that may seem inappropriate. I have had students make (and I have made myself) comments that on the surface sound rude, but could just be a misstatement (young people, after all, often have trouble expressing themselves). Conversely, I have had students say things that I took to be in jest when they were dead serious. Over time, I have learned a few things to help me in my teaching: For example, I learn to ask students for clarification and restatement - a skill we expect students to learn themselves.
QUOTE 3: "But it is obviously not possible to act thoughtfully and self-confidently while doubting oneself at the same time."
This quote was interesting for me because it puts me in two minds. On the one hand, it is true, students look up their teachers as figures of authority (intellectual, emotional, moral) and any sign of weakness can be disruptive to the class dynamic. I have had teachers who allowed their doubt to show and there were students who exploited that. On the other hand, I have had teachers who, by never doubting themselves, became authoritarian in the classroom. I think there needs to be a balance between being confident and being reflective, and I think (in opposition to the author) that there are occasions where the teacher needs to be reflective in class. Perhaps the teacher can choose those moments to reflect appropriately - for example, while the students are working on a problem or writing exercise. In any case, it is interesting that even the question of self-reflection is one that teachers need to self-reflect upon.
Thanks for this deeply thoughtful reflection! We'll be talking in class today about the double-edged sword of praise... I like your analogy to an athlete who makes many decisions without the time to reflect, much like a teacher, and I like your idea of stepping back to ask students to clarify and restate things. Tact includes 'always erring on the side of kindness', I think, and even then, it's quite possible to get things wrong from time to time.
ReplyDelete